In the Era of Open Banking, 'Positive Skeptics' Have a Crucial Role to Play
A skeptic is someone who habitually doubts commonly accepted beliefs. They are the naysayers, waiting in the wings to shoot down every great idea. But this does not mean that all skeptics are necessarily negative or cynical. In fact, positive skeptics play a vital role in our quest to modernize payments and banking, because they don’t automatically reject ideas. Instead of asking ‘why?’, they say ‘why not?’ They evaluate new ideas against the available evidence, instead of defaulting to ‘the way we have always done things’. They play devil’s advocate to innovate and create; a crucial role in an increasingly busy financial services marketplace.
Can Immediate Payments Prove Illuminating?
Over the last three years, ACI and Ovum have conducted a survey on how financial institutions see payments fitting into their broader strategic objectives. This often highlights the disconnect between the technology people and business people at a bank. Despite the many proven use cases for immediate payments, 6% of this year’s survey participants still see no benefit in real-time payments, mostly because they consider real-time to be a payments technology, not an essential part of a digital-first, customer-centric transformation strategy. Admittedly, the naysayers are trending downwards (it was 11% in the 2016 survey), but nonetheless it indicates how easily a market-leader can be left behind, or even be knocked out during a period of rapid industry change, simply by failing to see what is in front of them. As a result, digitization has led to the decline of some long standing ‘analogue’ market leaders across industries.
The Link Between Fast and Open Payments
As we move towards the era of open banking, organizations need team members who can draw parallels between the proven benefits of immediate payments, and wrap this into their evaluation of open banking strategies. We’ve already seen evidence that Open APIs help unlock that the true value of real-time payments.
A worrying number of payments decision makers say they see no benefit in open APIs (28%). They need the positive skeptics to push the agenda, or they will fall behind. Given the focus on proven use cases, it’s not surprising that 45% are waiting to see what others do before exploring the technology for their organization. This is a dangerous position to take – we know that being an agile business, first to market with innovations is the key to success in the New Payments Ecosystem. 65% of financial institutions report that Open APIs can help improve the customer experience, and 59% of banks do have a clear Open API strategy. It is far better to deploy at least a little curiosity and experimentation to avoid the risk of falling completely behind.
Open Banking Without Borders
The need for positive skeptics goes beyond the regulatory borders driving open banking within Europe. Open banking is a catalyst for global change. In Europe, PSD2 is a key driver, but open banking is also an opportunity to reengineer systems and offer innovative services to banks’ customers by taking advantage of new fintech propositions – as well as monetizing your own business in new ways. If you are going to innovate, you need to ask the right questions.
You have to ask: “what new services will help consumers manage their daily lives?” This is not about payments needs alone.
By operating within these open ecosystems, banks can credibly compete with global tech giants when it comes to personalized assistance propositions, and avoid being disintermediated from their core businesses of payments. The positive skeptics also need to ask: “how are we going to compete with the tech giants in payments?” – new entrants to the market will not all be startups.
The Tech Giant Invasion
A positive skeptic open banking mindset has already been adopted by a number of Asian tech giants that now offer all-in-one mobile apps that can also access and transfer funds – not just for traditional banked customers, but also for a new generation of consumers transacting electronically for the first time. Open APIs are paramount the key to enabling this explosion of digital payments via mobile phones and social media apps. The likes of WeChat Pay, Alipay and others have partnered with international retailers and tourism service providers to capture payments made by the growing number of outbound Chinese tourists in a simple, intuitive manner. They looked beyond their traditional marketplace, and considered the customer experience ecosystem beyond banking.
Harmonious Coexistence for Old and New
In the United States, banks are looking to leverage Open APIs as a way of modernizing not only their customer-facing retail payments business, but also to overcome the shortcomings of legacy systems that sit behind the payments engine, including core banking! The drive to realize digital transformation, while also saving costs, is forcing banks to take a fresh look at how to move away from cumbersome, obsolete, legacy technology.
When their positive skeptics ask, “how do we couple modern environments and consumer payment experiences with legacy systems?” the answer is flexible, agile technology that has a strong non-functional basis – and offers orchestration via Open APIs.
Go Forth and Question
The era of open banking is upon us, and there’s no question that banks must implement a strategy to meet these challenges, and maximize the opportunity. My advice to banks on the cusp of digital transformation would be to provide a platform for positive skeptics to ask, “can we do better?”, and to listen to their forward-thinking leaders.
Learn more about achieving open payments in this video: Build a platform for open banking
Related Blog Posts
Hat in Hand with 17 Heads: Payments Innovation and the Fraud Pitfalls to Avoid
Imagine that you live in a world that is revenue-agnostic, where payments revenue is so far decoupled from the payments channels that they ride on, and that startup culture and venture capital allow for the creation of all sorts of innovations that have some creative monetization that keep the train on the tracks. If you got halfway through that horrific sentence and realized we’ve been there for quite a while already, I’m impressed. It is essentially the cornerstone of banking, in many capacities.
Time is Money: A Millennial View of UK Faster Payments’ 10th Anniversary
As a millennial, I’ve often been the butt of jokes of those a little bit older than I am (whether colleagues or my own family). One of the clichés perpetuated is that we are constantly glued to our smartphones: In a way that’s correct, but misses an important point. As a young millennial professional, the most important thing to me is TIME. And that’s the reason my phone plays a crucial role in my life – much to the annoyance of my girlfriend and family. It means I can do things on the move, which in turn makes my life a whole lot easier.
Pints, Penalties and Payment Fraud: Welcome to the World Cup
You’d think that England already had the World Cup in the bag, based on the nationwide scenes of jubilation after the Three Lions’ penalty-takers had gone against the (painful) grain of football history, and emerged victorious at the end of a scrappy match against Colombia. However, those cries of “It’s Coming Home” from English football fans may just be a little premature, given that there are still three matches to play (and win) before the English can lay claim to being world champions for the first time in half a century.
Success Speaks: Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Talks Meeting Member Demands in Healthcare
When looking for a payments success story in the world of healthcare, you’d be wise to turn your attention to the Great Lakes and the work done by Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (BCBS MI). In a recent webinar with AHIP (America’s Health Insurance Plans) and ACI, Faran Farooqi, Strategic Capability Implementation and Operations for Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan, shared his insights into how his organization addressed the challenges of today to deliver a great payments experience for their members.
Innovate and Integrate to Accumulate: Investing in Payments Systems to Drive Growth
Today’s merchants face numerous challenges, which boil down to one central issue: how to succeed in a constantly changing, complex market, while also investing for the future.
Merchants need to deliver on growing expectations around the customer experience in an increasingly competitive environment, while battling growing costs and squeezed margins. This pressure extends through the whole business for every merchant, in every sector, and it’s driving merchants to look into every corner of their operations for ways to cut costs and redirect resources.
Taking Payments and Fintech for Granted? (A Lyrical Edition)
Based on a very quick search of the Googles, there are 128,014 songs that contain the lyrics “take for granted”— from the likes of Mary J. Blige, Social Distortion, Madness and Frank Sinatra as well as countless other great (and not-so-great) crooners. And that would make for a sizable Spotify playlist… and I do love my Spotify playlists (I’ve been on a Wham! kick lately).
Instant + Open Payments = A Winning Combination
I recently joined a panel discussion at EBAday 2018, alongside representatives from across the payments ecosystem, and the clear consensus was that real-time payments will be the new normal. This was evidenced by some of the interactive polls carried out.
Choice and Flexibility Help Digital Entertainment Merchants Catch Their Customers
Gaming and Digital Entertainment is one of the fastest growing verticals within the broader merchant sector, as boundaries continue to blur. Many forms of entertainment that once only took place in the physical world, or through the purchase of physical goods, have gone fully digital – with significant ramifications for businesses that provide payments services to suit a wide range of merchant needs. I spoke with Andy McDonald, ACI’s vice president of merchant payments, to find out more.
The Telco Transformation Tight Rope: Balancing Risk and Reward
In a previous blog post, we looked at the towering mobile payments opportunity for those MNOs and MVNOs that can build customer trust and convenience through innovation to become a digital marketplace.
But, it is safe to say that while the digital marketplace model could be a real opportunity for telcos, taking this route is not without some risk.
Consumer Payments: Will ‘Request for Payment’ Be the Next 'Big Thing'?
This week, NatWest announced that it has teamed up with British mobile phone retailer Carphone Warehouse to trial a new online shopping system that lets customers pay directly through their bank account, without using a debit or credit card.