The Hidden Cost of Digital Payments for Retail Payment Players
It is not exactly breaking news that non-cash payments are on the rise globally, with column inches dedicated to the launch of digital financial-inclusion projects. But going cashless is not only a challenge for humanitarian endeavors, or developing countries. We all agree that removing cash from the system will save payments players big bucks in the future, but we must also consider the immediate impact of digital transformation on the legacy infrastructure of the powerhouses of the payments ecosystem.
The U.S. is a global leader when it comes to per capita non-cash transactions, with 421/year per inhabitant. But historically, the way this market has dealt with non-cash transactions has been distinctly non-digital; up until the last decade, Americans still flagged check as their favorite non-cash alternative. Consumers and businesses alike seem unable to wean themselves off paper, despite the cost to both parties; issuing a check costs $3 on average (compared to 30 cents for an electronic transaction) and consumers can pay up to $20 for replacement checks.
The long-tail of legacy infrastructure
Why do checks continue in U.S. circulation, when many European banks stopped issuing them years ago? The answer lies in the particular challenges of the American market. The central bank lacks the regulatory power to phase out checks, and the highly fragmented nature of the system compounds the issue; over 10,000 depository institutions. So, if the drive to digitalization can’t come from the Fed, it must come from the market.
The appetite for improved digital payments in the U.S. is clear when we look at channels with low barriers to entry, such as Venmo. The fact that consumers will pay for an improved digital experience is evidenced by the launch of its new premium service, with 25c immediate payouts to debit cards. The free option is still available for those willing to wait three days.
The explosion in digital payment volumes won’t come from P2P alone. Improved digital experiences for retail are poised to play a huge part. A survey of American users found that the average person with an Amazon Echo spent roughly $1,700 a year on Amazon (as of Sept. 30, 2017) compared to $1,000 for all U.S. Amazon customers. The convenience of ‘invisible’ payments, initiated by voice, contactless devices or biometrics is driving up consumer spending via digital transactions, and the industry knows it; according to the Digital Banking Report, 71% of financial institutions surveyed considered “transferring money between accounts or making payments” as an “extremely” or “very important” part of their future voice capabilities.
Why isn’t the total value of low-friction digital payments increasing in line with the volume?
Legacy retail payments infrastructure is throttling the market. The burden of increased digital payment volumes weighs most heavily on merchant acquirers, as legacy systems struggle to scale to the new volumes coming from increasingly digitized merchants. These existing systems are the bedrock of the American economy, and have remained untouched for 20 years for good reason; because they work!
In payments, downtime, outages, lost and failed transactions are all unacceptable, so any upgrades need to maintain the excellent Non-Functional Requirements (NFRs) of the foundational solutions. The temptation is to take an ‘if it ain’t broke…’ approach, but the risk for these payments players really lies in doing nothing. If acquirers cannot scale to meet merchants’ digital transaction volumes, then merchants will find a provider who can.
In light of this, it comes as no surprise that 31% of banks in the Americas are increasing their concentrated investment in modernizing payments technology, to meet these new demands. This represents an 18% rise from 2016. Those wishing to invest wisely are steering clear of homegrown solutions, given that the primary drivers for retail banks’ investment include increased operational efficiency, reduced risk, and rapid expansion of services to meet customer demands. For retail banks and other merchant acquirers, payments solutions are critical to their core business. They cannot dedicate the necessary resources (financial, technology, or human) to building, maintaining and innovating in payments software at the accelerated pace the market demands.
The path to New Payments Ecosystem success lies in acknowledging the importance of innovating and implementing solutions that enable this without breaking the foundations of your business. Solutions must meet the scalability, availability and reliability that customers demand (consumers and merchants alike).
Discover your path to the New Payments Ecosystem with our guide to digital transformation.
Related Blog Posts
How Italian Banks and Processors Can Capitalize on Digital Transformation
The European payments landscape is in an era of significant change thanks to PSD2 and other macro factors, but there is more than one way to deliver real-time and open payments to meet PSD2 requirements and its technical standards. Banks and processors must manage this alongside their own set of domestic challenges and opportunities.
SWIFT gpi: Leveraging Cross-Border Payments for the Real-Time World
SWIFT gpi represents the evolution of business done over the SWIFT network, bringing correspondent banking into the digital era.
I’ve covered this topic before, but with gpi now reaching the two-year milestone, it’s a good chance to reassess the progress that has been made – and what is needed to drive further adoption.
Instant Payments in Italy – And Beyond: Lessons from Il Salone dei Pagamenti
ACI was invited back to Il Salone dei Pagamenti – Italy’s premier payments event organized by the Italian Banking Association (ABI) – to participate in a panel, “SEPA Inst – the Future.” As expected, the session was packed with stats and advice for a more efficient roll out of instant payments – in Italy and beyond.
Dedicated Followers of Fintech: Why Transaction Banking Never Goes Out of Fashion
Taking part in a panel at a recent corporate treasury conference, I was introduced as a ‘consumer payments expert’ – not an obvious qualification for sharing stage-time with serious corporate liquidity and cash management folk, but as the talk track was on mobile wallets and Open Banking, I had some reasonably safe and relevant content on which to fall back.
Sibos Preview: The Five Trends Transforming Real-Time Payments
Real-time is now a reality, with more than 30 schemes live around the world. And real-time is in the spotlight as banks and financial service providers make their way to Sydney for Sibos 2018. What better time to look ahead at the key trends that are going to shape the ongoing development of real-time payments.
API Management: The Reason Digital Open Banking Can Fly
When it comes to thinking about the different roles that an API Manager can play for an organization, I personally think that an airport provides the perfect analogy. The customer is the passenger, the third-party organizations using a bank’s APIs are the airlines and the airport itself is the bank. I also think this analogy helps to visualize the variety of API management capabilities – including the role of an API gateway.
Can Corporate Banking be as Easy as Ordering Pizza?
ACI recently hosted Greenwich Associates on a webinar to discuss corporate banking. While not a topic that would usually make attendees salivate, the discussion turned toward ordering pizza (maybe, because it was close to lunchtime) and Greenwich highlighted how corporate banking should be as easy as ordering pizza.
Modernizing Cross-Border Transfers with SWIFT gpi
The customer experience for domestic payments – retail and corporate – has recently undergone a complete transformation. There’s still plenty more that could be achieved, but the advent of real-time payments in combination with open APIs has seen the launch of Request for Payment services and direct eCommerce instant payments in the UK and Europe. And it’s not just the PSD2 push in Europe that’s driving change – in the U.S., Zelle is moving beyond standalone P2P payments to become an integrated part of the retail banking app experience, as well as being included in new kinds of corporate disbursements.
Instant + Open Payments = A Winning Combination
I recently joined a panel discussion at EBAday 2018, alongside representatives from across the payments ecosystem, and the clear consensus was that real-time payments will be the new normal. This was evidenced by some of the interactive polls carried out.
Maintain Vs. Invest: What the Digital Era Ushers in for Banks
Taking place this week in Brussels, the European Credit Research Institute (ECRI) will host a high-level debate on how policymakers can build on the process of digitalisation of banks to raise competitiveness in light of increased competition from fintech start-ups and tech giants.