Blockchain for Retailers: Producing Real Business Benefits
When I read about blockchain, I typically come across three use cases: cross-border payments, security issuance and digital currency. These have all been proven to work—and they are also finance-related. But the payments ecosystem includes a lot more than just financial institutions. This post explores the potential impact that blockchain will have on retailers and their value chain.
For those new to blockchain, I will give a simple definition (for those who understand it, feel free to skip this paragraph). A blockchain is essentially a record, or ledger, of digital events — one that is “distributed,” or shared between many different parties. A blockchain can only be updated by consensus. It is a distributed database that maintains a continuously growing list of data records.
What are the blockchain use cases?
The industry has coalesced around four groups of use cases. Within each group, there are many different use cases. My intent is to describe each use and give a practical example of how this use case has been deployed by a retailer.
Smart contract code is code that is stored, verified and executed on a blockchain. Smart legal contracts is the use of the smart contract code that can be used as a complement, or substitute, for legal contracts. In its simplest form, this is about "if X happens, do Y," without any human intervention. Use cases include anything from rental cars or apartments, through to complex machine-to-machine transactions involving advanced analytics.
In October 2015, it was announced that Visa was working on a smart contract proof of concept (PoC) for car leases and rentals. Visa worked with DocuSign to create the solution with the aim of reducing or completely eliminating paperwork that customers need to go through during the car rental process.
The Visa-DocuSign PoC involves registration of each car on the blockchain using a unique digital identity assigned to them. The car’s digital identity is then connected to a Visa payment channel and also to the DocuSign platform.
Whenever a customer wants to rent a car, they can pick the car of their choice and finish the formalities online while sitting inside the car itself. Beyond selecting the type of car, they can search, compare and choose insurance plans as well as other in-car payments like tolls, parking fees, etc. It is possible to enable all of these services by authenticating preferences using a DocuSign electronic signature. The information will be updated on the blockchain against the car’s unique identity, which can be readily accessed by the company.
Digital Currency & Fraud Reduction
Digital currency and fraud reduction is one of the oldest use cases for retailers. Of course, blockchain technology started with Bitcoin and has spawned many imitations. In 2014, Overstock.com became the first major retailer to accept Bitcoin as a payment. As the use of alternative payment methods explodes, retailers must be cognizant of the ways that consumers want to pay. Use of Bitcoin is still low, but could increase in the event of a financial catastrophe. With the finite number of Bitcoins available and the power required to mine for new coins, the value of Bitcoin might skyrocket and consumers holding the currency may want to change their virtual currency for physical goods.
The nature of blockchain technology makes it difficult for actors to create fraudulent entries on the ledger or alter existing entries. Typically in retail, every actor in the supply chain must pay a third party to validate the exchange of goods and money. Payments can be delayed as transactions are confirmed, which can be crippling for smaller businesses.
Placing the transactions on a blockchain platform will reduce the need for validation and improve the transparency of exchanges, settling funds transfers faster and reducing identity fraud. With every transaction verifiable and recorded on a ledger, there is a significant reduction in fraud.
Record keeping is perhaps the most complex use case, but one with tremendous value. It has many sub-use cases;
1. Transparency is of increasing importance to consumers. Provenance is a platform that helps brands provide that transparency by tracing the origins and histories of products. Consumers could trace the seafood they eat from boat to plate. Or verify that the wool sweater they just bought came from sheep that are humanely treated. Blockchain underpins this transparency, allowing all parties—supplier, manufacturer, retailer and end consumer—to trace a product’s journey.
2. Reducing counterfeit goods has been a problem that has plagued manufacturers and retailers for years. Block Verify is a blockchain-based anti-counterfeiting solution for pharmaceuticals, luxury items, diamonds, and electronics. Goods can be certified with blockchain’s digital ledger record, which mean that stolen merchandise can also be more easily recorded.
3. Warranties are often problematic for consumers. A growing number of consumer-focused companies are already using Warranteer, a service that moves product warranties from paper onto the cloud via blockchain, keeping them up-to-date and easily transferable. Consumers are able to maintain a virtual warranty wallet, saving retailers and manufacturers administrative work.
4. Supply chain modernization has been talked about in the industry for many years. Wave, still in testing, has targeted the global supply chain, hoping to modernize the receipt of cargo for shipment (import bills of lading or BoLs) with blockchain. The company has created a peer-to-peer and completely decentralized network that connects all parties of the international trading supply chain. Using decentralized technologies, all communication between these parties will be direct, eliminating the need for them to pass through a specific central entity. Connecting all members of a supply chain to the decentralized blockchain allows for a direct exchange of documents between them, solving one of the shipping industry's largest problems.
Walmart, IBM and Tshingsu University started working together in October 2016 to explore food supply chain traceability and authenticity using blockchain technology. The project comes as Walmart announced its new Food Safety Collaboration Center in Beijing.
Their goal is to improve the way food is tracked, transported and sold to consumers across China, harnessing the power of blockchain technology designed to generate transparency and efficiency in supply chain record-keeping.
I briefly mentioned securities earlier as one of the primary use cases in finance. Security issuance can be broken into two components: debt and equity. In terms of debt equity, Overstock is still a pioneer in blockchain technology adoption. The company started a new subsidiary, the T0 platform, which issued the first Overstock cryptocurrency bond. As a result, the SEC granted Overstock approval to issue public equities.
Nasdaq has launched its platform, Linq, marking the first time a company facilitated private share issuance using blockchain technology. Nasdaq has enabled issuers of equity to digitally represent a record of ownership in order to significantly reduce settlement time and eliminate the need for paper stock certificates.
There are a lot of use cases for blockchain technology, and the business case for each needs to be developed. A lot of companies exist that have a blockchain solution for a problem that does not exist—essentially a hammer searching for a nail. The use cases outlined have common benefits focused on simplifying existing relationships, reducing fraud and improving the speed of commerce. These benefits result in freed up capital and improved cash flow, as well as stronger relationships with both consumers and suppliers. A retailer cannot do this in isolation. As the saying goes, “it takes a village to raise a child.” In this case, the child is blockchain – young and full of potential. The village is the retail ecosystem: suppliers, consumers and regulatory bodies. Working together, they can harness the potential of blockchain and help it mature into a useful and practical technology, which provides real business benefits.
ACI Worldwide is attending and exhibiting at MRC Vegas, March 13-16. Andreas Suma, vice president, Fraud & Data, will take a deep dive into blockchain use cases in the breakout session ‘Blockchain Technology – What is it and What Does it Mean for Your Business?’ on Wednesday, March 15, 2:45-3:30pm.
Related blog posts
The Constant of Change and the Future of Commercial Banking
Let’s clarify this before I lose anyone; the self-proclaimed “pioneer of wisdom,” noted Greek philosopher Heraclitus, is credited with the saying Panta rhei, "everything flows." More commonly, you have probably heard this as “the only constant is change,” but either way, this teaching has withstood the test of time, as it is not only applicable, but feels like a worldly truth when I find myself talking about today’s transaction banking landscape. A robust time of change is upon us; one that has brought us to the precipice of a new era in banking. Understanding the driving forces behind this change as well as embracing new business models will be a key to success, or even to survival.
The Hidden Risk of Complacency
Available in Spanish and English
As a professional in Latin American electronic payments, I often forget how it is to live not knowing what’s going on backstage every time I use my cards. My specialization makes me aware of trends worldwide, so while traveling, I’m able to analyze different technologies in action. My consumer side, also known as my ‘shopaholic’ side, exposes me to multiple situations, since any trip—be it business or leisure—always provides a good opportunity to shop. On a recent trip, I had the chance to experiment with my Argentinian cards during a semi-long-term stay. While out of country for 40 days, I experienced first-hand the challenges that consumers encounter with the EMV payments barrier.
Driving Toward Innovation in Digital Banking User Experience
The need for delivering on a user experience strategy necessitates the use of common and sometimes confusing lingo like CX, UX, information architecture, UX design and UI design. It introduces ways to gain deeper understanding of customers through methods like personas, journey mapping and Kano analysis. It commands phrases like customer-centric, experience-driven, and ideation/visioning. In the past 4 months, I have interviewed more than half a dozen agencies to engage one that could go beyond the buzzwords and the methods described above. I want to be convinced that great and meaningful changes can happen to UI’s. After all, talk is cheap.
Have US Issuers Done Everything To Help Customers Transition To EMV?
U.S. consumers with chip-and-signature cards may find some merchants outside the U.S. (and particularly in Europe) that are unwilling or unable to process their cards, even though they have embedded chips.
Bold Demonetization Plan Leapfrogs India Ahead in Electronic Payments
Indian Prime Minister Modi’s demonetization program launched on November 8th—with the objective of curbing fraud by removing counterfeit and illegally gained currency (aka “black money”) from circulation—is an incredibly bold initiative, which has short and long-term impacts for India and the global economy. Some have called this “the single biggest decision taken by the Indian government since Independence.” The surprise move will invalidate approximately 86% of all cash, as hundreds of millions of people exchange currency in the lead-up to the December 30th deadline to replace all invalidated notes.
Sweeping and overnight changes in Indian banking sector
In August, 2015, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) approved 11 Payment and Savings Bank licenses to firms across India, which will be allowed to accept deposits, provide payments services and distribute third-party financial products, but not to lend or issue credit cards. Ranging from nascent FinTechs to established stalwarts like the Department of Posts (the mail delivery system of India), the progressive introduction of payment banks will make way for new entrants serving hundreds of millions of banking customers in India—and these new banks won’t require all of the formalities of traditional banks to bring competition to the marketplace.
Fintechs seeking bank charters? Yes, really.
The common understanding in the industry is that, as bank regulators gradually inch their way toward regulating financial technology companies that transact banking, lending, and payments, the fintech companies are retreating, trying to move as far from those regulators as possible, for as long as possible. The industry narrative is that, when the regulatory heat eventually gets too high, the fintechs will change business models, or combine with other companies, or seek to be acquired by the very banks they now compete against.
The Tech Free Payments Utopia or is it a Dystopia
Copenhagen has quickly become one of my favorite cities in the world, a hidden gem to quote that travelin’ man with the soothing voice, Rick Steves. While exploring this great city one evening after the inaugural Money20/20 Europe, my intrepid Rantings partner (Mark) and I happened upon the quirky hamlet of Christiania, and it was during this (very quick) stroll through the autonomous anarchist society that we started turning over the idea of a tech free utopian society. The conversation took a break as we saddled up to a shawarma vendor to indulge in one of my favorite street treats.
Multiple payment options delightful or detrimental
Day one of the first-ever Money20/20 Europe is nearly in the books here in Copenhagen and to say that today was anything short of a full day would be an understatement.
The Land of Vikings and FinTech
We are less than a week away. I have been brushing up on my Hans Christian Anderson stories, watching Disney’s The Little Mermaid more or less on repeat for the past month in anticipation to going to the great author’s stomping grounds for Money 20/20 (truth be told: my two-year-old daughter has the movie on repeat so you could say I fell into this one).