The Mexican Fintech Revolution – ¿Qué onda in Open Banking?
Mexico has joined an elite group of nations, being amongst the first to pass open banking regulations. Specifically designed to open up its financial services and technology sector, the so-called ‘Fintech Law’ appears to have taken notes from PSD2, UK Open Banking, Singapore’s ‘organic’ approach, and others – and balances these against Mexico’s unique context and aims.
ACI’s Lu Zurawski, one of the industry's foremost open payments experts, and Sonia Gomez, a Latin America payments authority, discuss this balancing act; including the drivers, the regulation and the potential benefits.
What is the new Mexican Fintech Law?
Lu Zurawski: Essentially Mexico has regulated that any banking provider must open up to provide fair access to data, if they want to secure or retain their banking license. This is a relatively aggressive approach that has echoes of PSD2 and UK Open Banking, compared to the more suggestive approach favored by Singapore’s regulator. What’s great is that the focus is very much on driving valuable digital engagements with the customer, rather than trying to monetize the base open APIs included in PSD2.
Mexico seems a world apart from Europe and the UK. What drove them to adopt a similar approach?
LZ: It may look worlds apart, but consider the original aims of the UK Open Banking regulations. The UK might seem very digitally inclusive today, but even five years ago it wasn’t such a level playing field. A large part of UK Open Banking was about forcing the industry to meet the needs of the underbanked; those who weren’t offered fair access to financial services. Fair access might have been around literal access via channels that met their specific needs, but consider that many of those with the lowest incomes were only able to access credit or loans through the most expensive means. The rise of the new, digital-only banks has been accompanied by a rise in fair access micro-credit for those at that end of the spectrum.
Sonia Gomez: This kind of financial inclusion is central to the Mexican Fintech Law. Mexico has a large population who are underbanked or completely unbanked. Then it also has exclusion zones based on lack of mobile internet coverage. The question of inclusion is broader than financial; it’s about digital inclusion for fair access to services. The Mexican government wants to drive competition with a view to creating new customer propositions, which attracts new users to the digital space. This could have socio-economic benefits beyond new, low-cost banking and payments services. A more evenly digitized population could be offered other governmental services via digital channels, reducing costs for the operator and freeing up resources to reinvest in the people.
LZ: The UK also designed its legislation to tackle its banking oligarchy, and Mexico has a similar challenge with lack of competition. The UK’s Big Four controlled not only most of the market, but also the central infrastructure. There’s a common misconception that the ‘fair access’ part of open banking refers only to fintechs accessing customer data, but that’s only a small part of the equation. For new players to bring new customer propositions to market, they need fair access to the infrastructure. Look at Transferwise, the first non-bank to gain access to the UK Faster Payments scheme. Previous sponsor-based models didn’t do enough to meet this need for fair access, but this was overcome by the Payments Service Regulator (PSR) working with the Bank of England (BoE) to offer settlement accounts to non-banks, in combination with direct access to the scheme.
SG: Integrating third parties into the Mexican payments ecosystem is a big driver, because it’s going to really support their aim of driving inclusion at the national level.
Does ‘third-parties’ just mean fintechs?
SG: In much of Latin America, we have the concept of Corresponsales Bancarios, or ‘non-financial correspondents.’ These tend to take the form of a local business that operates as channel access to some basic financial services. These stores provide some payment services; bill payment, providing ‘cashback,’ etc. The new regulation could help formalize some of these businesses or organizations, which provide much-needed services in communities with low digital adoption, into new kinds of challenger community banks.
LZ: Open banking is just a small part of the wider open data discussion. Mexico is ahead of the curve here, having hosted the Open Government Partnership Global Summit in 2015. Open is about supporting people in understanding their own data to make informed decisions. That decision might be about banking services, or utilities providers, healthcare or insurance plans. A challenger community ‘bank’ could be exactly the sort of place to aggregate open data services into a friendly-face, which supports the consumer in accessing and understanding their data. Education will be critical to the success of open banking and open data.
SG: Leveraging these non-financial correspondent operators, whom the local community already trust, would be highly effective in the Mexican context, where there is unfortunately a history of corruption that breeds mistrust amongst many of these communities.
LZ: There’s also a huge opportunity for foreign banks to capitalize on a fast-growing market. If they invest to meet PSD2 open banking requirements, then they can also look to take advantage of the new Mexican environment, ahead of the competition. They might be giants in their home markets, but here they – along with smaller start up entities – have the most to gain. Effectively, limitations on market share by incumbents have been lifted, and the winners will be those who can add value to the customer.
What kind of open banking, payments and data services could the Fintech Law enable in Mexico?
LZ: The first step is for the industry to look at success stories, but the model to emulate is not the UK or Europe, or even China, where high smartphone usage (even if low levels of digitalization) was a common feature. India is a much more comparable environment, with a large digital ‘gap’ and plenty of feature phones in circulation and where the government looked to bring telcos into the payments ecosystem. Licensed telco-oriented financial services providers are well positioned to understand the front-end use cases, and can partner with payment providers in delivering those new propositions. It requires partnerships to monitor, understand and combat the new risks. The Indian approach to mobile payments was fairly gentle and organic (unlike demonetization) and has been very successful.
SG: Delivering new digital propositions via non-smartphones is a proven channel in Latin America. Colombia’s DaviPlata from Davivienda had a hugely successful pilot and has been extended to include government disbursements and social media payments integrated into a smartphone-app to meet the evolving needs of the population. DaviPlata was also successfully leveraged in partnership with Corresponsales No Financieros. In my opinion, the next step in financial and digital inclusion is to incorporate fair micro-loans and micro-credit into these propositions. Latin American struggles with ”gota a gota,”, or loan sharks, because many people cannot access credit via reputable financial services providers. This can often be linked to historical violence and upheaval, resulting in large numbers of internally displaced people, who suffer a break in their credit history, or interruptions to their history as a whole. They struggle to access all kinds of services via mainstream providers, so they turn to informal (and sometimes illegal) providers in desperation. Fintechs that can find ways to aggregate their fragmented history and link it to a micro-loan proposition, delivered via context-appropriate channels, would really meet the needs of the local population.
LZ: And this speaks directly to fair access! There are plenty of examples around the world where individuals are unfairly disadvantaged when it comes to accessing credit or loans. In the UK, the government ran its Rent Recognition Challenge to tackle exactly this issue. Early stage success for Bud, a new AISP (Account Information Service Providers) and PISP (Payment Initiation Service Providers) under PSD2, is gaining fair access to account information to create fair mortgage access for consumers.
What will be most crucial to the success of the Fintech Law in meeting its inclusivity aims?
SG: Education of the people in order to build trust in both the existing institutions and these new service providers, and education of the service providers to ensure they understand the Mexican context and bring new offerings that meet the needs of the people.
LZ: I’d also say education. This is one of the less successful elements of the UK Open Banking project. There has been too much focus on systems, infrastructure and regulation, but too little on customer education. This is necessary to shut down conspiracy theorists and ‘big brother’ rumors. The issue in the UK has been that noone can agree who should be responsible for delivery of these education programmes. But the success of the investment relies on consumer adoption, and that relies on education of the population. As the Mexican Fintech Law evolves beyond the initial framework, I believe they should regulate the involvement of participants in such educational initiatives.
Discover more about the global shift to open payments. Watch the video with Lu Zurawski: “APIs and the Rise of Open Banking”
Related Blog Posts
The EMV Deadline Has Been Extended for U.S. Fuel Merchants – Now What?
U.S. fuel stations were originally supposed to be EMV-compliant by October 2017, but due to complications and costs at the time, the deadline for EMV at the pump was extended for three years – and it has now been pushed out further to April 2021 due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Merchant Fraud in the Age of COVID-19: We Need to Prepare Ourselves for a “Tidal Wave” of Attacks
With millions of consumers around the world self-quarantining at home, online shopping for goods, services and entertainment has become the new normal for many. A recent analysis of our own data has shown that average transaction volumes in the retail sector in March rose 74 percent compared to the same period last year.
Are Chargebacks Making a Comeback for U.S. Fuel Merchants?
With the planned EMV implementation date looming for U.S. fuel merchants, we’ll be spending some time ahead of the October 2020 deadline looking at the fraud issues affecting fuel merchants and how these might change through the final quarter of this year.
Rebirth of The High Street: An Unintended Consequence of COVID-19?
You don’t know what you’ve got until it’s gone. How true that is right now for the U.K.’s High Street (or for that matter local retailers in communities around the world) and our desire to shop.
Merchant Considerations for Protecting Payments During the COVID-19 Crisis
As the spread of COVID-19 continues to impact businesses of all shapes and sizes in unprecedented ways, the power of payments has never been clearer. Drastic increases in online transaction volume and the need for essential in-store payment processing create new challenges for online and brick-and-mortar retailers alike. Here are a few ways that merchants can protect their business – from the perspective of payment processing and fraud mitigation – during this uncertain time.
Positioning PSPs for Success in 2020: Scalability, Flexibility and Globality
We used to say that NFRs (non-functional requirements) such as scalability and availability didn’t really make for attention-grabbing headlines, but in fact, 2019 has shown us that these NFRs are often not far away from the biggest stories. A major outage or downtime – be it for bank or merchant – makes headlines in its own right, but we’re increasingly seeing a clear link between NFRs and a company’s growth trajectory. Those companies that are generating positive awareness from their ambitious global expansion plans, innovative customer experiences, or unique approach to fighting fraud – they are achieving this off the back of technology solutions that deliver world-class non-functional requirements. Scalability, flexibility and globality underpin these growth stories – and this message comes out clearly in speaking with some of our leading payment service providers (PSPs), which are supporting the growth of thousands of merchants around the world.
Three Merchant Payment Trends to Watch in 2020
In 2019, merchants everywhere were challenged by pressure from new entrants, the continued breakdown of traditional industry boundaries and growing customer preference for a digitally-led or digitally-influenced purchasing experience.
Learn How to Claim a Greater Slice of the Mobile Payments Pie
U.S. Wireless Players: $14.3B is at stake – are you in?
Mobile commerce is thriving as consumers seek out convenient, quick and secure shopping experiences. And transaction growth on mobile devices is outpacing traditional desktop and in-store channels, aided by click and collect and one-click purchasing trends. For U.S. telcos, the message is clear: proactively add value to the payments process, or risk missing out on increasing your portion of the growing mobile payments market.
How to Survive Black Friday and Cyber Monday… and Provide a Great Consumer Experience
As Black Friday and Cyber Monday approach, shoppers and merchants alike await amazing deals and a welcome boost in sales, respectively. I took a moment to speak with two of ACI’s merchant payments and fraud experts, Andrew Marshman (merchant payments lead, Europe) and Erika Dietrich (VP, Global Fraud Prevention Risk Services) about what merchants need to know as they head forth into one of the biggest shopping seasons of the year.
Strong Customer Authentication in Australia: Reducing CNP Fraud and Streamlining eCommerce Payments
Minimizing fraud without harming the customer experience can be done – using the right tools
In 2017-18, card-not-present (CNP) fraud cost Australian eCommerce AUD $478 million and accounted for some 85 percent of all fraud on Australian-issued cards1. In 2016, CNP fraud in Europe represented 70% of all card fraud2. Seriously uncomfortable numbers.