Despite the Hype, Machine Learning, Models, Behavioral Profiling and the Customer Experience are Still Fundamental
Think about the last time you got a fraud decline. Where were you? In the grocery store? Buying airline tickets? On holiday? Shopping in the same place you’ve been a dozen times, but across the border? How frustrating was that, what did it do to your perspective, your mood, your confidence in your financial institution? This can be embarrassing and inconvenient, stressful and alarming for the consumer. There are few things that can be more disruptive in our day-to-day lives then the lack of access to your funds, or the care taken by your financial institution after a fraud occurs. According to ACI’s Global Consumer Fraud Survey, 20% of people may decide this is too much and move along to another financial institution.
How can we harness payments data and manipulate it to determine if a transaction is legitimate (or more accurately, if it is not) and reduce customer churn? Here’s a guide to some of the advanced analytics that can underpin a successful approach to fraud detection. This should allow you to start separating the hype around artificial intelligence, from the machine learning, neural and regression models and the rule-based logic we have all come to embrace in the practice of making sausage in a fraud shop.
The role of behavioral profiling and adaptive machine learning
Enter behavioral profiling, the capacity for one’s own behavior to influence fraud detection strategy. The merchants we typically visit, the fuel pumps where we get gas, common travel destinations, these are all a part of the behavioral profiling technology that we’ve been using for years. Questions arise… How often do we buy from retailers that sell women’s ready-to-wear clothes? What’s the potential that someone will spend their holiday in Belize? Is this an unusual amount that someone is taking out at this ATM and is it the first time they are using this specific terminal on the other side of town? The technology to evaluate these scenarios has been around for a while, it’s mature and widely accepted as the “table stakes” feature functionality to reduce risk of fraud and maintain a good customer experience.
Behavioral profiling is also useful in models, whether it be a regression model (expanding on the example above at the ATM), neural scoring models, or going down the rule-based machine learning path. Adaptive machine learning will typically leverage multiple data sources, using up-to-date variables to provide the greatest possible timeliness in both legitimate and fraud transactions. This integration of many data points and risk indicators may include; recent fraud trends, legitimate spending patterns including non-monetary transaction elements like the addition of beneficiaries or changes to demographics, end-point device intelligence, resident malware indicators, authentication results and third-party or internal scoring models.
So, while all these elements are assembled together into a larger complex regression model, there is one additional element that can be integrated into the model that enhances it with statistical properties; the risk-weighting of the various signals and data elements inside of the regression model. This allows for the model to accurately assign an optimized predictive capability to these data elements, which will then accurately calculate the relative risk of the data element. This process produces reliable and repeatable decisioning logic, identifies insights into the legitimacy of the transaction and provides value relative to historical relationships and trends, aligning the model logic to inbound transactions, recognizing patterns and delivering the value of advanced analytics in fraud detection.
But is AI ready for primetime?
Pattern recognition in supervised machine learning (where the machine is provided example inputs, perhaps exemplified in the data elements described above) is not a new science; we’ve been delivering these models for years. What is new is the hype around this process and the introduction of Artificial Intelligence (AI) concepts in the fraud detection space. Here’s the deal with unsupervised AI… it’s not ready for primetime, performing under the legacy supervised machine learning analytics applications that are deployed presently in the smarter financial institutions and processors. It’s simply not fast enough, smart enough or cheap enough to be implemented at scale, so when you hear people say AI and fraud in the same sentence, you might be smelling actual fraud.
AI is suggested, expected and advertised to be the technology holy grail that will reduce human supervision and oversight, minimizing the manual analytical work load and constant strategy maintenance that is the backbone of any fraud analytics team. The end goal of AI is to get the computer to minimize the amount of work from humans and transition it to the machine, ultimately to realize a lift in efficiency and accuracy in fraud detection. The computer can indeed do things faster than humans, but the human will always know better about the reasons behind the signals… and for this reason, while the goal is admirable, its unlikely to be fully realized.
Utilizing the existing supervised machine learning strategies is presently delivering the best probability of aligning the stars of a high detection rate AND a positive customer experience. This is again, table stakes for financial institutions as the culture of fraud detection moves further toward the best customer experience metrics. Because I shouldn’t get a decline when I am going back to Arizona for Christmas again or having my favorite meal at that one Poutinerie in Montreal with the best smoked meats. But if you’re my bank and you fail to detect more than a transaction in a country I’ve never been to, I’ll be upset over it.
Every new payment type brings new fraud challenges – download our whitepaper 'The Fraud Trap: Optimizing Digital Payment Controls from Day One' [PDF] to find out more.
Related Blog Posts
Instant Payments in Italy – And Beyond: Lessons from Il Salone dei Pagamenti
ACI was invited back to Il Salone dei Pagamenti – Italy’s premier payments event organized by the Italian Banking Association (ABI) – to participate in a panel, “SEPA Inst – the Future.” As expected, the session was packed with stats and advice for a more efficient roll out of instant payments – in Italy and beyond.
Dedicated Followers of Fintech: Why Transaction Banking Never Goes Out of Fashion
Taking part in a panel at a recent corporate treasury conference, I was introduced as a ‘consumer payments expert’ – not an obvious qualification for sharing stage-time with serious corporate liquidity and cash management folk, but as the talk track was on mobile wallets and Open Banking, I had some reasonably safe and relevant content on which to fall back.
Sibos Preview: The Five Trends Transforming Real-Time Payments
Real-time is now a reality, with more than 30 schemes live around the world. And real-time is in the spotlight as banks and financial service providers make their way to Sydney for Sibos 2018. What better time to look ahead at the key trends that are going to shape the ongoing development of real-time payments.
API Management: The Reason Digital Open Banking Can Fly
When it comes to thinking about the different roles that an API Manager can play for an organization, I personally think that an airport provides the perfect analogy. The customer is the passenger, the third-party organizations using a bank’s APIs are the airlines and the airport itself is the bank. I also think this analogy helps to visualize the variety of API management capabilities – including the role of an API gateway.
Can Corporate Banking be as Easy as Ordering Pizza?
ACI recently hosted Greenwich Associates on a webinar to discuss corporate banking. While not a topic that would usually make attendees salivate, the discussion turned toward ordering pizza (maybe, because it was close to lunchtime) and Greenwich highlighted how corporate banking should be as easy as ordering pizza.
Modernizing Cross-Border Transfers with SWIFT gpi
The customer experience for domestic payments – retail and corporate – has recently undergone a complete transformation. There’s still plenty more that could be achieved, but the advent of real-time payments in combination with open APIs has seen the launch of Request for Payment services and direct eCommerce instant payments in the UK and Europe. And it’s not just the PSD2 push in Europe that’s driving change – in the U.S., Zelle is moving beyond standalone P2P payments to become an integrated part of the retail banking app experience, as well as being included in new kinds of corporate disbursements.
Instant + Open Payments = A Winning Combination
I recently joined a panel discussion at EBAday 2018, alongside representatives from across the payments ecosystem, and the clear consensus was that real-time payments will be the new normal. This was evidenced by some of the interactive polls carried out.
Maintain Vs. Invest: What the Digital Era Ushers in for Banks
Taking place this week in Brussels, the European Credit Research Institute (ECRI) will host a high-level debate on how policymakers can build on the process of digitalisation of banks to raise competitiveness in light of increased competition from fintech start-ups and tech giants.
How the Merchant Payment Ecosystem Can Create Value in Instant Payments
Recently, ACI conducted some research into the appetite to make use of instant payments among corporates. The results were overwhelmingly favorable, but when we think about the benefits of immediate payments for corporates, it does seem obvious that they would want to leverage this new payment type.
Real-Time Payments Will be Europe’s Most Dominant Payments System – Are You Ready to Realize the Full Value?
Since the launch of the SCT Inst rulebook in November 2017, many more banks are live and offering real-time payments to their customers, with most of the rest committed to 2018. The buzzword at the recent ECB #TIPSapp Event in Frankfurt was ‘Interoperability,’ or as my friend José Beltrán from STET would say, ‘Reachability.’ No-one expressed this more clearly on February 6th than Javier Santamaria, President of the European Payments Council, when he reiterated his message from Il Salone Dei Pagamenti, the day after the SEPA launch; "We have launched the Pan-EU scheme, now it is up to you in the audience and beyond to take advantage of it and make it work."