To Regulate Or Not To Regulate – Is That Thy Question?
Debates are healthy, and as someone who spent a little time during my college years dabbling around the edges of the speech and debate team, I can tell you it’s something that I personally relish. A chance to really talk through the pros and cons of an argument and lay out the bare facts… and then be judged based not only on those facts, but on the presentation and power of persuasion—sign me up!
My wonderful and insightful colleague, Paul “A Brit living in Omaha” McMeekin, recently shared his insights on the opportunity for Open Banking to take root at a state level in the US, but he’s skirted the main issue on this topic – or just assumed it to be fact; a folly many less seasoned debaters have made. The fact is that we need some regulation for Open Banking to take hold, which remains an open question here in the US.
The number 1 ‘pro’ of regulation is uniformity and a ‘call to action.’ The biggest hurdle we face is inaction. But at the end of the day, to reach the potential of open banking utopia, banks are going to have to invest a lot of money. We’re talking billions of dollars; just look at the news on what Nationwide and RBS have recently committed to as part of their transformation plans.
In the parts of the world where PSD2 and Open Banking are mandated, it’s no longer a choice of whether to embark on these projects; it’s necessary to operate efficiently and effectively in the new world of finance. This spend will effectively position those institutions to rapidly take advantage of newer and newer technology as the innovation cycle accelerates, while the financial institutions not undertaking this will inevitably put their legacies at risk.
And the number 1 ‘con’ of regulation? Cost and “what if we’re wrong?” As noted in the primary ‘pro’ above, the cost of re-architecting/platforming a bank is no small task. The cost will be measured in trillions (as an industry) by the time the dust settles… and what if we’re wrong? What if consumers simply don’t want any of these new technology-driven financial tools and payments options? I am hopeful that the latter POV is fading, as early usage for new payment types and alternative payment options flourish globally. However, the incumbents maintain a massive position of strength (as they own a clear majority of deposit accounts and financial transactions today).
I have stood by my view that market competition in the US is strong enough to move the ball forward on Open Banking, and we have seen a thaw in terms of creating partnerships, which even five years ago many of us would have said were never going to happen (Goldman Sachs and Acorn, Suntrust and Kabbage, to name a couple).
However, if we’re going to see Open Banking or digital banking ecosystems reach their full potential, it’s going to have to be less focused on driving revenue in current business models, and more on attracting data flows due to new value propositions – something that will inevitably lead to those new revenue streams that may make today’s revenues look like drips from a faucet.
Now that’s how you debate!
Mark Ranta will join top payments executives at the Leadership Loft at Money20/20 USA, for a session titled: “Return of the Planet of the APIs: The New Payments Ecosystem,” 4:00 – 4:40pm on Tuesday, October 23. In this session, experts will discuss how traditional boundaries that once defined the payments landscape have been removed with APIs.
Meet ACI at Money 20/20 at Veronese 2502, October 21-24. For more information, visit ACI at Money 20/20.
Related Blog Posts
European Banks Have the Right Tools to Stay Ahead – But Will Big Tech Overtake?
Open banking and immediate payments have come a long way, according to the panellists who joined me during the ‘Open Banking in an Instant World’ session at EBAday in Stockholm recently. The building blocks are now falling into place through the introduction of national and regional schemes, open banking initiatives, regulations such as PSD2 and the acceptance and use of APIs.
Checkout Optimization Challenges: Top Tips for Online Merchants
As the current conference season draws to a close, it’s time to reflect on one of the key topics topping the agenda for many online merchants: checkout optimization.
How Banks and Acquirers Can Deliver on the Benefits of PSD2 SCA Exemptions and Differentiate Their Merchant Services
PSD2 is an opportunity for acquirers to differentiate themselves by delivering improved services to their merchants, if they implement modern solutions to manage SCA exemptions. This will drive the best customer experience in combination with regulatory compliance.
How UPI is Driving India's Shift from Cash to Digital Payments
The Indian economy has traditionally been heavily dominated by cash, while experiencing low adoption of various online payment systems including National Electronic Funds Transfer (NEFT), Real Time Gross Settlement (RTGS) and inter-bank mobile payments. The dominance of cash is evidenced by the ratio of cash withdrawals at ATMs vs debit card usage at Point of Sale (POS)—ATM transaction volume is more than 2x greater than POS.
Cooperation, Consultation and Collaboration Are the Keys to Countering CNP Fraud in Australia
As Europe, and other parts of the world ramp up for regulatory changes around PSD2, Australia is about to launch its own strategy to combat Card Not Present (CNP) fraud.
PSD2 and Strong Customer Authentication – What's in Store for Merchants?
With the final pieces of the Payment Services Directive (PSD2) puzzle coming together, payments businesses are highly focused on meeting their compliance obligations. But the forthcoming changes will affect everyone in the payments chain – and it’s important for merchants and PSPs to understand the practical implications for their businesses and customer relationships.
Transforming Telecom Companies in a Retail World
The recent MVNO World Congress in Amsterdam brought fascinating insights into the changing telecom industry, particularly around the opportunities that lie ahead for Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs) and how they can they can cement their position in today’s fast-paced climate.
Success Speaks: Surprising New Ways Students Want to Pay
Colleges and universities are facing the dual tasks of accommodating not only new payment methods, but also a new generation of students, Gen Z, whose expectations differ greatly from even millennials. How can higher education institutions meet these demands?
In our latest Success Speaks webinar, experts from Temple University, FutureCast, ACI and MTFX Group of Companies explored today’s payments landscape for colleges and universities, payment desires of Gen Z, innovations the higher education sector is already implementing and how schools can better assist with international payments.
Women Must Choose to Rise Up Despite Past, Current and Future Circumstances
Money20/20, Europe’s biggest payments and fintech event, was recently held in Amsterdam and featured Rise Up Money20/20, a global program designed to address the gender imbalance in leadership positions within the financial services and fintech industries. A cohort of 30 female professionals was selected to take part in an exclusive curated agenda, complete with a series of bespoke content sessions, one-to-one mentoring and unique networking opportunities.
Beyond Borders: Navigating the Challenges of eCommerce Expansion
eCommerce continues to flourish, with impressive growth figures year after year. In 2018, global online sales reached almost $3 trillion, and are expected to hit $4 trillion by the end of 2020.
Despite eCommerce taking an increasing slice of the retail pie (which could now be as high as 15 percent according to recent figures), it is increasingly challenging, with competition and cost pressures creating significant issues for merchants of all sizes.