Why Open Banking Might Need to Rely on a Magic Illusion of 24x7 Availability
The adage “the more things change, the more they stay the same” appears to ring true when applied to the early phases of the evolution of open banking (or open payments). Especially when you contrast it with the early days of ATM withdrawals; particularly those made in the dead of night so you could pay cash for your after-party greasy feast.
Both scenarios require that a real-time balance is available to ensure that cleared funds are honored. Decades ago, consumer demand for accessible after-hours cash was resolved through the illusion of real-time account availability, made possible by clever systems like BASE24, which safely managed balances even when old-fashioned account systems retired overnight to attend to their batched-up housekeeping duties.
That illusion has been perpetuated over the last couple of decades, and it appears that the same magic is now needed by banks obligated to provide 24/7 real-time balance data to third parties in new Open Banking initiatives. That’s because many banks’ modern Open Banking capabilities, delivered using new technology constructs like Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) and real-time payments, are still dependent on core banking systems with the same old limitations.
Real-time authorization for the digital era
It is an interesting paradox that many of the world’s biggest retail banks (and indeed a fair proportion of disruptive new banks) are investing in user experience-driven banking apps to support always-connected users – but taking the capabilities of core accounting systems for granted. New, easy-to-use, front-end apps are important, obviously, but it is a mistake to view the core authorization systems just as rather boring ‘back office’ overheads. These services are a crucial piece of the ‘always connected’ design goal, and to offering high levels of personalization.
The modern requirement for personalization builds on traditional authorization functions (i.e. “is the card valid?” “are there sufficient funds?) by layering on extra preferences, such as the ability to turn accounts on/off, creating geographical blocks and restricting usage by retailer segment. Further checks need to be made to avoid fraud and to comply with new regulations relating to authentication requirements, where multi-factor authentication (beyond traditional card and PIN) needs to be executed.
New “authentication ceremonies” will need to be supported – allowing consumers to approve transactions using safe and secure methods that feel most natural. These are needed when a consumer accesses a bank directly using the bank’s own services. But they are also needed for indirect access, for example, when a consumer uses a third-party provider’s app to access the bank via new Open Banking APIs. Modern authorization and authentication systems are anything but ‘back office’ – they are about to become major customer service differentiators.
Understanding Open Banking transactions flows – what happens when it goes wrong?
The new world of Open Banking promises new innovative services, offered by both new companies and by established brands now able to aggregate information from consumers’ multiple bank accounts and to initiate payments on their behalf. However, there are some uncertainties in these new transaction scenarios – not a great surprise given the new and radical nature of some of these interactions, which is giving rise to varying interpretations of public policy and regulatory statements.
Arguably, new payment flows might be simpler; real-time (immediate) payments as an alternative to cards carry the promise of lower costs, faster settlement and no provision for disputes and chargebacks. But normal people can make mistakes and queries, so disputes and correction facilities will inevitably need to be provided. In the card payments world, the ownership of liability and risk for these scenarios is clearly prescribed by the card schemes. But, in the world of Open Banking, these operational support facilities still need to evolve.
The existence of equivalent rules and policies in card payments ensures the continued use of cards as the default payment rails – at least until we see improved definitions for liability ownership within the real-time and open payments market.
What new magic is needed to deliver modern Open Banking?
So, is a 24/7 illusion still needed in the era of modern open banking?
It seems evident (and somewhat surprising) that many contemporary financial institutions are still not operating truly 24/7 core processing systems. There are exceptions, particularly among the new breed of start-up banks dotted around fintech capitals of the world, but in general the need for a resilient proxy to manage real-time balance information still exists.
It may no longer be sufficient to stick to the old magic tricks, however. In addition to the basics of safe transaction authorization, modern transaction handling systems need to step up to the challenges of strong authentication, the complex logic of personalized financial services and being able to handle alternative payment methods.
It may be appealing to dispense with the magic and go to the core of the problem – upgrading existing banking systems to become genuinely real time. This can be a high-risk strategy though, fraught with existential dangers that go beyond the world of payments. It’s also a high cost, long term option. Tricky, if business needs to keep their options open as consumer opinions (and the actions of regulators) start to shake out.
The real trick is to make sure that customers get what they want. No one needs to believe in magic for this to work – you just need to recognize that magical things can happen if you get the payments story staged right.
View our infographic, which outlines a real-time balance use case that meets Open Banking requirements.
Related Blog Posts
European Banks Have the Right Tools to Stay Ahead – But Will Big Tech Overtake?
Open banking and immediate payments have come a long way, according to the panellists who joined me during the ‘Open Banking in an Instant World’ session at EBAday in Stockholm recently. The building blocks are now falling into place through the introduction of national and regional schemes, open banking initiatives, regulations such as PSD2 and the acceptance and use of APIs.
Checkout Optimization Challenges: Top Tips for Online Merchants
As the current conference season draws to a close, it’s time to reflect on one of the key topics topping the agenda for many online merchants: checkout optimization.
How Banks and Acquirers Can Deliver on the Benefits of PSD2 SCA Exemptions and Differentiate Their Merchant Services
PSD2 is an opportunity for acquirers to differentiate themselves by delivering improved services to their merchants, if they implement modern solutions to manage SCA exemptions. This will drive the best customer experience in combination with regulatory compliance.
How UPI is Driving India's Shift from Cash to Digital Payments
The Indian economy has traditionally been heavily dominated by cash, while experiencing low adoption of various online payment systems including National Electronic Funds Transfer (NEFT), Real Time Gross Settlement (RTGS) and inter-bank mobile payments. The dominance of cash is evidenced by the ratio of cash withdrawals at ATMs vs debit card usage at Point of Sale (POS)—ATM transaction volume is more than 2x greater than POS.
Cooperation, Consultation and Collaboration Are the Keys to Countering CNP Fraud in Australia
As Europe, and other parts of the world ramp up for regulatory changes around PSD2, Australia is about to launch its own strategy to combat Card Not Present (CNP) fraud.
PSD2 and Strong Customer Authentication – What's in Store for Merchants?
With the final pieces of the Payment Services Directive (PSD2) puzzle coming together, payments businesses are highly focused on meeting their compliance obligations. But the forthcoming changes will affect everyone in the payments chain – and it’s important for merchants and PSPs to understand the practical implications for their businesses and customer relationships.
Transforming Telecom Companies in a Retail World
The recent MVNO World Congress in Amsterdam brought fascinating insights into the changing telecom industry, particularly around the opportunities that lie ahead for Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs) and how they can they can cement their position in today’s fast-paced climate.
Success Speaks: Surprising New Ways Students Want to Pay
Colleges and universities are facing the dual tasks of accommodating not only new payment methods, but also a new generation of students, Gen Z, whose expectations differ greatly from even millennials. How can higher education institutions meet these demands?
In our latest Success Speaks webinar, experts from Temple University, FutureCast, ACI and MTFX Group of Companies explored today’s payments landscape for colleges and universities, payment desires of Gen Z, innovations the higher education sector is already implementing and how schools can better assist with international payments.
Women Must Choose to Rise Up Despite Past, Current and Future Circumstances
Money20/20, Europe’s biggest payments and fintech event, was recently held in Amsterdam and featured Rise Up Money20/20, a global program designed to address the gender imbalance in leadership positions within the financial services and fintech industries. A cohort of 30 female professionals was selected to take part in an exclusive curated agenda, complete with a series of bespoke content sessions, one-to-one mentoring and unique networking opportunities.
Beyond Borders: Navigating the Challenges of eCommerce Expansion
eCommerce continues to flourish, with impressive growth figures year after year. In 2018, global online sales reached almost $3 trillion, and are expected to hit $4 trillion by the end of 2020.
Despite eCommerce taking an increasing slice of the retail pie (which could now be as high as 15 percent according to recent figures), it is increasingly challenging, with competition and cost pressures creating significant issues for merchants of all sizes.