Analyzing Annoyance? Online Shopping Behavior at the Checkout
If you’re standing at the checkout in a brick-and-mortar store, it’s easy enough to see when fellow customers become agitated and annoyed. Impatiently checking the time, audible ‘harrumphs’ and negative body language are all tell-tale signs that the payment process is not proceeding as smoothly as desired. But how does this frustration manifest itself in online shopping behavior?
The tyranny of distance removes all physical cues, but it is crucial for online retailer to identify and address points of friction, in order to improve the overall digital shopping experience and maximize conversion rates.
Tracking purchases online, for example through clicks and conversions, does yield data that payment providers can use to refine checkout and digital payment processes. It has been shown, for instance, that including the three most popular alternative methods of payment in any given market can increase a merchant’s conversion rate by up to 30%. Services such as those offered by ClickTale go deeper, with heatmap analytics and other powerful tools to understand online shopping consumer behavior. But a another recent study may add something new to payment providers’ and merchants’ analytical arsenal – the ability to analyze annoyance in shopping online.
New insights into online shopping behavior
Jeffrey Jenkins, an information systems expert, led the research into how negative emotions – including anger, frustration, and confusion – can be detected through mouse movements.
According to his Brigham Young University study, "How mouse movements can determine emotions", when consumers are upset or confused, mouse movements become jagged and imprecise, rather than following a straight or gently curving path. Somewhat counterintuitively, upset consumers also tended to move their mouse cursor more slowly. The ability to process sufficient data in order to draw such conclusions was a requirement for the study, which could potentially have a range of practical implications for web developers seeking to reduce pain points that generate negative emotions.
“Traditionally it has been very difficult to pinpoint when a user becomes frustrated, leading them to not come back to a site,” said Jenkins. “Being able to sense a negative emotional response, we can adjust the website experience to eliminate stress or to offer help.”
Reducing friction at the checkout
The resulting digital technology has already been patented and spun off to a local startup company that holds the license. How exactly this may be developed for use in the payments and eCommerce space remains to be seen, but the continued “API-ization” of payments means that it is conceivable that common shop plugins already used by merchants could quite easily integrate this analytical technology.
As a result, payment providers and merchants could gain a more precise understanding of the aspects of the online shopper checkout experience that evoke negative emotions. Just how annoyed do online shoppers get when a page loads slowly? Does confusion really reign when users are taken off page to complete their payment? Is frustration evident when certain types of payment methods are not available, or fail to function as they should? What about 3D Secure? These are all things that can increase friction, and ultimately lead to a high shopping cart abandonment rate – the last thing a merchant wants. A better understanding and actionable insights can only be a benefit, especially when optimizing conversion rates can have such an impact on revenues.
But what about mobile?
The study in question is predicated on the presence of a mouse cursor, but with mobile shopping set to overtake traditional desktop eCommerce (mobile share of all online purchases is expected to be 40% by the end of the 2015 and the 50% “tipping point” not far behind), both payment providers and their merchants may be focusing attention elsewhere. A “mobile first” strategy will mean reducing friction and improving mobile payment flows, and gaining a deeper understanding of mobile shopping behavior. Whether a similar “analysis of annoyance” will be possible on touchscreen devices, via swipes and taps, remains to be seen (though the BYU study tentatively suggests it is possible).
The bottom line is that payment providers and merchants need to keep an open mind to using these sorts of new digital technology and tools that are being developed, in order to optimize payment setup across all channels.
Related Blog Posts
Increasing Collections & Satisfaction: Real-Time Payments for Loan Servicing
The old adage that “cash is king” is precisely that: old. In today’s world, convenience is king and real-time payments deliver it in spades. Consider that convenient ways to pay can reduce late payments by up to 76%, while reducing call center volumes by up to 83%, and it’s no wonder lenders are expanding their offerings over time to include checks, ACH, debit cards and now real-time payments.
A Master Class in Convenience: Faster Payments for Higher Education
Paying for college can be a real pain, and the act of paying tuition itself has not kept up to speed with the times.
According to Aite Group, 40% of tuition payments are made by ACH (electronic check), making it the most popular method of payment for higher education. Yet, these payments can sometimes take several days to process. In a world where college students send and receive over 120 text messages per day, immediacy is key. Especially when large dollar amounts are being spent. Students and parents demand that payment options conform to their expectations of speed, to prevent their accounts from being overdrawn.
A Prescription for Profitability: Real-Time Payments Come to Healthcare
When it comes to important numbers in the healthcare sector, you’re probably familiar with 120/80 (that’s ideal blood pressure for the non-medically inclined), but I’d like to introduce you to two more numbers: 15 and 47.
15 is the percentage of healthcare spending due to billing and payment inefficiencies, while 47 is the percentage of patients who would leave a hospital for a better payment experience1.
How the Merchant Payment Ecosystem Can Create Value in Instant Payments
Recently, ACI conducted some research into the appetite to make use of instant payments among corporates. The results were overwhelmingly favorable, but when we think about the benefits of immediate payments for corporates, it does seem obvious that they would want to leverage this new payment type.
Instant Payments Are at the Heart of the New Global Payments Landscape: 10 Trends to Watch in 2018
2017 was a big year for immediate payments: European Banking Association, Real-Time 1 (EBA RT1) SEPA Credit Transfer Instant, The Clearing House (TCH) Real-Time Payments in the U.S., and the Australian New Payments Platform (NPP) schemes, all either going live, or in the case of Australia, about to go live. These schemes enable real-time payment transfers across the United States, 34 European countries and Australia, with the potential to reach nearly another 1 billion people. This comes on top of the existing live schemes in the UK, China and India, so that over half of the global population now can access real-time payments solutions.
Real-Time Payments Will be Europe’s Most Dominant Payments System – Are You Ready to Realize the Full Value?
Since the launch of the SCT Inst rulebook in November 2017, many more banks are live and offering real-time payments to their customers, with most of the rest committed to 2018. The buzzword at the recent ECB #TIPSapp Event in Frankfurt was ‘Interoperability,’ or as my friend José Beltrán from STET would say, ‘Reachability.’ No-one expressed this more clearly on February 6th than Javier Santamaria, President of the European Payments Council, when he reiterated his message from Il Salone Dei Pagamenti, the day after the SEPA launch; "We have launched the Pan-EU scheme, now it is up to you in the audience and beyond to take advantage of it and make it work."
When Is Processing Payments in The Cloud More Secure?
Back when I started my career, “Jessie’s Girl” by Australian rocker Rick Springfield topped the charts, the federal funds rate was 20 percent and most organizations were reliant upon one or more mainframe computers that were hosted in an internal “computer room.”
Immediate Payments Require New Business Models First, It Solutions Can Come Later
Hungary is probably not the first country that comes to mind when talking about fintech hotspots and innovation hubs. However, the country is very much at the forefront when it comes to banking innovation in Europe. In late 2017, I had the privilege to speak at the annual Fintech Innovation Conference in Budapest. Organized by Privatbanker.hu, this was a great opportunity to meet not only Hungarian experts, but finance professionals and industry stakeholders from across the continent.
Four Customer Experience Golden Rules for Real-Time Bill Payments
Faster. Instant. Real-time. Immediate. Whatever you call it, Real-Time Payments are transforming how we pay for goods and services on a global scale. And, The Clearing House just announced the US real-time pilot is now live!
The Art of Open Banking, Part 2: on the March
In the first part of my talk with @digitalbankguru (aka Mark Ranta) and @Lui_Zurawski (aka Lu Zurawski), we discussed plans that best prepare an organization for Open Banking, and in this second chapter, we explore some use cases for delivering value.