Latest Durbin Ruling: Who Pays?
A U.S. judge recently rejected the Durbin Amendment, saying the Federal Reserve inappropriately inflated debit card transaction fees and failed to provide merchants with multiple, unaffiliated networks for each debit card transaction.
This ruling affects billions of dollars as debit card usage has grown significantly over the past five years. It's all being done in the name of the consumer. But is the consumer the one ultimately footing the bill?
Assuming the federal government has the of best intentions, its intervention in these matters is done to protect the consumer and help prevent one side from taking advantage of the other. The banking community and the related associations had created a revenue stream via the growth of debit card transactions, at the expense of the merchant taking payment from the consumer. But what typically happens when a merchant incurs additional expenses? They pass them on to the consumer buying goods and services. A cost such as this, baked into every day prices, is usually unnoticeable. But there is a breaking point.
The merchants felt the transaction fees to be too high, and countered by filing suit against the guts of the Durbin Amendment. Now that a judge has ruled in their favor (if upheld), it would reduce a profit line banks have come to rely on as other areas of revenue have been pinched and squeezed. What typically happens when a bank incurs additional expenses? They pass them on to the consumer who uses their banking services. This cost is more noticeable, as the banks will look to make up the loss in profit by eliminating benefits the consumer has grown to know, such as free checking.
Where the ball lands in this legal volley between financial institutions and merchants will probably end up being more beneficial for one versus the other. But when the dust settles, the consumer will be the one left holding the bill. It then begs the question: Is it better to have less outside intervention into these situations (ie the federal government) and let the market play itself out?
Latest Durbin Ruling: Who Pays? by Sean Guilfoyle
Related Blog Posts
How to be a Payments Trailblazer – The Seven Habits of Highly Innovative Organizations
The new Culture of Innovation Index from Ovum and ACI identified segments—from banks to intermediaries to merchants to corporates—at the cutting edge (of innovation) across the payments ecosystem. But what is most notable about those segments that have reached ‘trailblazing’ status is the apparent lack of commonality between them. No one segment, nor one region fosters better innovation. In fact, what’s driving these segments/organizations to be best of breed is their own culture of excellence. The only thing they have in common is their attitude.
Customer Innovation: Erste Bank [Q&A]
The global banking sector is becoming both more strategically focused and technologically advanced, responding to rising consumer expectations while trying to defend market share against an increasing array of competitors. A great deal of emphasis is being placed on digitizing core business processes, and reassessing organizational structures and internal talent to be better prepared for the future of banking.
Regulating for Real-Time: The Role of Government in Payments Modernization
Dr. Leo Lipis and Craig Ramsey, Head of Real-Time Payments for ACI Worldwide, continue their discussion on real-time payments and the findings of the new white paper, Get More from Real-Time.
Issuing and Acquiring in a Real-Time and Open Payments Ecosystem – The Global Picture
Dr Leo Lipis and Craig Ramsey, Head of Real-Time Payments for ACI Worldwide, continue their discussion on real-time payments, stemming from the findings of the new white paper, Get More from Real-Time. See part one.
Four Questions to Drive Your Retail Banking Payments Strategy in 2019
I keep hearing that it’s “an exciting time to be in payments,” and I certainly agree that there is a lot of noise. However, when I look below the surface, I’d argue that the interesting activity is not with the payment itself, but with all the related events and steps in the value chain.
What Can the Re-Regulation of Other Industries Tell Us About Open Banking One Year On?
UK Open Banking just reached its first birthday milestone (on January 13 to be precise) and given my own commentary – including in the ACI blog – on this topic, the first anniversary of Open Banking in the UK certainly won’t pass without a debrief on the progress that’s been made and what challenges lie ahead.
Instant Payments in Italy – And Beyond: Lessons from Il Salone dei Pagamenti
ACI was invited back to Il Salone dei Pagamenti – Italy’s premier payments event organized by the Italian Banking Association (ABI) – to participate in a panel, “SEPA Inst – the Future.” As expected, the session was packed with stats and advice for a more efficient roll out of instant payments – in Italy and beyond.
To Regulate Or Not To Regulate – Is That Thy Question?
Debates are healthy, and as someone who spent a little time during my college years dabbling around the edges of the speech and debate team, I can tell you it’s something that I personally relish. A chance to really talk through the pros and cons of an argument and lay out the bare facts… and then be judged based not only on those facts, but on the presentation and power of persuasion—sign me up!
Request for Pay – What Does It Mean For Financial Institutions?
What do banks – one with $60B+ in assets, one a mid-size regional bank, and one, a small innovative credit union – have in common with payment networks and the ‘Big 4’ consulting firms? They were all part of the first ACI #PaymentsForBreakfast event in North America! The theme was real-time payments, but the focus was more specifically on Request for Pay.
Why Open Banking Might Need to Rely on a Magic Illusion of 24x7 Availability
The adage “the more things change, the more they stay the same” appears to ring true when applied to the early phases of the evolution of open banking (or open payments). Especially when you contrast it with the early days of ATM withdrawals; particularly those made in the dead of night so you could pay cash for your after-party greasy feast.