Is the future of money digital?
Wednesday, May 09, 2012
Posted by Pam Latulippe
The Pew Research Center recently released a report called The Future of Money in a Mobile Age, in which they asked experts in the field whether or not technology will have eliminated the need for cash or credit cards in the United States in the next 8 years.
65% of the experts agreed that we would move away from cash and credit. So the headline many touted was “Cash banished by 2020, say experts!” However, when taking a closer look, you see that the experts were asked to agree with one of two statements.
Here’s the statement 65% of experts agreed with:
By 2020, most people will have embraced and fully adopted the use of smart-device swiping for purchases they make, nearly eliminating the need for cash or credit cards. People will come to trust and rely on personal hardware and software for handling monetary transactions over the Internet and in stores. Cash and credit cards will have mostly disappeared from many of the transactions that occur in advanced countries.
And here’s the other statement, which 33% of experts said they agreed with:
People will not trust the use of near-field communications devices and there will not be major conversion of money to an all-digital-all-the-time format. By 2020, payments through the use of mobile devices will not have gained a lot of traction as a method for transactions. The security implications raise too many concerns among consumers about the safety of their money. And people are resistant to letting technology companies learn even more about their personal purchasing habits. Cash and credit cards will still be the dominant method of carrying out transactions in advanced countries.
Obviously, these two statements are very different, taking opposite points of view. The reality will likely end up being a combination of the two scenarios, and not simply due to security and privacy concerns. In order for people to embrace and fully adopt mobile payments as a replacement for cash, funds must be moved instantly from one bank account to another at a different bank. Currently, in the U.S., those person-to-person payments move along the same rails as checks, which can take a few days. When people send cash using their mobile phone they expect the funds to transfer immediately. They are not likely to adopt a system where funds transfers are delayed. If the banks find a way to solve this, even if it means taking on the credit risk to deliver instant money transfers between individuals, more people will be ready to go cashless.
However, even if there is a way for person-to-person payments to transfer immediately, there must be more of an incentive for people to make purchases at the point-of-sale with their mobile phones other than just convenience. People are more likely to use their mobile phone instead of cash or plastic if they receive a discount or accumulate loyalty points as a result. What’s more, banks, retailers, mobile carriers and others involved in the development of mobile wallets will need to educate consumers on the benefits of moving money via mobile phones in order to change behavior on a large scale, and that will take time, perhaps more than 8 years.
What do you think? Are we headed for a definite future with mobile money as a primary payment method, or will it be something a minority of Americans will embrace?
Related blog posts
Alarming Brazilian Card Fraud Trends & Outlandish Risky Behavior
In a recent report “Global Consumers: Losing Confidence In The Battle Against Fraud,” it was found that 30% of consumers have experienced card fraud in the past five years. Against a backdrop of 2,260 confirmed data breaches in 2015 and over 4 billion records stolen since in 2013, consumers are losing faith in the ability of providers to protect them.
South African Card Fraud Trends & Risky Consumer Behavior
In conjunction with the PASA International Payments Conference this week, we decided to take a look at some recent consumer fraud data from the host nation, South Africa. The market is very similar to the global averages, in that a shockingly high number of consumers continue to experience card fraud. Despite the number of fraud attacks and breaches, consumers in South Africa continue to engage in risky behavior such as providing information in phishing attempts and writing down their PIN numbers.
July: the hottest shopping time of the year for consumers, retailers—and fraudsters
Summer is in full swing, and while many people equate this time of year with beach-hopping and BBQs, retailers—and those of us who keep them in business— are quickly making July one of the most exciting shopping months of the year. Irresistible online sales and promotions abound, and with that, so does the risk of fraud. In fact, eCommerce fraud attempt rates in July, 2016 (1.6%) are slightly higher than fraud rates in December, 2015 (1.2%), which is the busiest holiday shopping time of the year.
2016 (Mid) Year in Payments Review
Ahhh summer - The Fourth of July (celebrating the original Brexit), Major League Baseball’s All-Star game (swap out the All-Star Game for UEFA Euro or Copa America for our friends off our shores) and the countdown to the lighting of the Olympic cauldron… the telltale signs that summer is in full swing and we have officially moved into the year’s third quarter. With all the pomp and circumstance of the continuous celebrations and backyard barbeques, I took some time to jot down my thoughts on the first half of 2016, and what I am excited to see unfold in the coming weeks and months as we march toward our fall conference schedule and the all-important holiday shopping season (22 weekends left until Christmas, hope you stocked up on Prime Day last week).
Aggregation Services Will Save Money
Payments used to be so simple. You went to your bank, gave them your money and sometime later it would arrive at the beneficiary, albeit not necessarily always intact in value. But the world has changed rapidly over the past decade as new payment providers have been offering services to targeted markets and customers. Their services have been more relevant to the end user than the generic products that many banks have continued to offer.
Three things that it takes to be in the Fraud Management Business in 2016; a survey reflection
On the heels of ACI’s latest Consumer Fraud Survey, recurring questions have continued to solidify themes. Let me summarize the results for you: There is incrementally more card fraud, consumers are not changing their behavior all that much in reaction to it, and they expect any issues to be addressed and resolved more easily today than in years past. Of course, this is about what we should be anticipating in our “always on”, service and convenience oriented, mobile world. So, with that said, here’s what fraud management means to consumers and fraud managers in 2016.
How Will You Pay for Your Cake by the Ocean
Ahh, summer. I don’t have that summertime, summertime sadness nor do I like the Motel’s Suddenly Last Summer. But with summer now in full gear, I am one to wax poetic about spending those countless days of younger yore in Newport (and Middletown), RI, while my Rantings cohort has been a long-time (part-time) resident of Cape Cod. But we’re not here to debate which beaches are better (because there’s no debate that RI’s beaches are superior, though Welfleet’s Beachcomber is among my favorite all-time summer bars). We’re here to rant about more prudent topics…like bucket lists, not buckets full of delicious steamers; in this case, we’re referring to summer fintech bucket lists (or perhaps summer fintech wish lists).
Immediate Payments Tide Continues to Rise
I recently had the pleasure of participating on an unusually high caliber payments discussion panel, sponsored by BayPay Forum, a Silicon Valley-based payment industry group. The Forum organizes some great events, most of which combine social networking with industry education on emerging payments trends.
The New Payments Ecosystem Fast Open and Disruptive
Sitting at the PayExpo event in London last week, you could feel the excitement that the payment industry is generating. Slightly weird feeling when I remember telling friends 15 years ago about payment trends (as you do) and watching their eyes glaze over. Now mobile wallets such as Apple/ Samsung Pay or AliPay; Fin-Tech payment intermediaries such as Transferwise or HiFX; sharing economy evangelists such as AirBnB or Uber; challenger banks like Mondo or Atom Bank—they’re making payments trendy, exciting and relevant to all.
Over 2/3 of Asian Payment Players See Their Business Being Disrupted By New Technologies
One of the benefits of working for a global company is the ability to speak to clients and colleagues from all over the world. During one of our lively discussions we talked about the commonalities across the globe and the differences. We decided to start testing our hypothesis – that banks, merchants and financial intermediaries have more in common in different locations than they tend to think. Of course, local culture, practices and languages are different but the big strategic forces they are facing are the same.