Is the future of money digital?
Wednesday, May 09, 2012
Posted by Pam Latulippe
The Pew Research Center recently released a report called The Future of Money in a Mobile Age, in which they asked experts in the field whether or not technology will have eliminated the need for cash or credit cards in the United States in the next 8 years.
65% of the experts agreed that we would move away from cash and credit. So the headline many touted was “Cash banished by 2020, say experts!” However, when taking a closer look, you see that the experts were asked to agree with one of two statements.
Here’s the statement 65% of experts agreed with:
By 2020, most people will have embraced and fully adopted the use of smart-device swiping for purchases they make, nearly eliminating the need for cash or credit cards. People will come to trust and rely on personal hardware and software for handling monetary transactions over the Internet and in stores. Cash and credit cards will have mostly disappeared from many of the transactions that occur in advanced countries.
And here’s the other statement, which 33% of experts said they agreed with:
People will not trust the use of near-field communications devices and there will not be major conversion of money to an all-digital-all-the-time format. By 2020, payments through the use of mobile devices will not have gained a lot of traction as a method for transactions. The security implications raise too many concerns among consumers about the safety of their money. And people are resistant to letting technology companies learn even more about their personal purchasing habits. Cash and credit cards will still be the dominant method of carrying out transactions in advanced countries.
Obviously, these two statements are very different, taking opposite points of view. The reality will likely end up being a combination of the two scenarios, and not simply due to security and privacy concerns. In order for people to embrace and fully adopt mobile payments as a replacement for cash, funds must be moved instantly from one bank account to another at a different bank. Currently, in the U.S., those person-to-person payments move along the same rails as checks, which can take a few days. When people send cash using their mobile phone they expect the funds to transfer immediately. They are not likely to adopt a system where funds transfers are delayed. If the banks find a way to solve this, even if it means taking on the credit risk to deliver instant money transfers between individuals, more people will be ready to go cashless.
However, even if there is a way for person-to-person payments to transfer immediately, there must be more of an incentive for people to make purchases at the point-of-sale with their mobile phones other than just convenience. People are more likely to use their mobile phone instead of cash or plastic if they receive a discount or accumulate loyalty points as a result. What’s more, banks, retailers, mobile carriers and others involved in the development of mobile wallets will need to educate consumers on the benefits of moving money via mobile phones in order to change behavior on a large scale, and that will take time, perhaps more than 8 years.
What do you think? Are we headed for a definite future with mobile money as a primary payment method, or will it be something a minority of Americans will embrace?
Related blog posts
As Aetna pulls out, how the member experience can increase exchange profitability
My heart sank when I did the math on Aetna withdrawing from many health insurance exchanges due to low profitability. Aetna could have avoided 2/3 of its losses by improving its member experience.
Aetna lost roughly $16 per member per month. But health plans can save up to $11 per member per month by enhancing the member experience. The key lies in automation, consolidation and service fees.
Rio 2016 – Once the Games are over, it doesn’t mean fraud is over
The 2016 Rio Games are in full swing—with great story lines and unbelievable performances by incredible athletes, all being watched and admired by a million additional tourists in town (not to mention the many billions watching on TVs and computer screens).
Assessing the impact of the MIF Regulation interchange fee caps
The European Regulation on Interchange Fees for Card-based Payments (or the MIF Regulation for short) came into effect in December 2015. Comprised of four main areas—interchange fee caps, acquirer pricing transparency, the separation of card schemes and processing, and other supporting rules—the regulation will have a profound impact upon the European payments industry and has the potential to reshape the eCommerce payments landscape. No area, however, is poised to cause more of a commotion than the interchange fee caps. Acquirers, card issuers, and payment service providers are all affected, but the impact of interchange fee caps—and what it means for their businesses—varies considerably.
Alternative Payments Will Present New Business Opportunities In The Middle East
The second survey in our ongoing series took us to Dubai and the Cards and Payments Middle Eastern Conference in early June. Much like the blog from Australia, we had some fascinating results but for entirely different reasons. Whilst 64% of the Australian payment experts we interviewed were concerned about being disrupted by new technologies and entrants, only 38% in Dubai agreed with this sentiment. In fact, 39% disagreed with this and said their business was not going to be disrupted by new technologies or entrants. Hmmm... Let’s try and understand the reasons for this huge difference…
ACI empowering girls to code
This summer, ACI had the distinct pleasure of hosting a ‘Coding for Girls’ camp in Omaha, with plans now underway to host additional camps every quarter. It should come as no surprise that women are underrepresented in tech and view tech-related hobbies as a complex, male-driven endeavor. And as such, young women frequently avoid coding altogether, so our great team embarked on this program for girls--introducing them to coding in a fun and interactive way.
Five or so payment stories, five rings = your Olympic payment preview (and a reminder not to stick your head in the water!)
Cue the athletes, start the music, release the doves… it’s time to shimmy down to your skimpy excuse for a bathing suit and head to Copacabana beach to celebrate the 2016 Rio Games (just don’t stick your head in the water)! For those of you lucky enough to be going to the Games, good for you; for the rest of us, we’ll have to read, listen and watch from afar…letting our imaginations fill in the blanks from the all-night parties I am sure will be rocking (and for those party-goers, don’t stick your heads in the water). My Rantings cohort and I will be among those watching from afar, with Mark likely focused on Michael Phelps and the other swimmers and me focused more on tennis player Leander Paes who’s participating in his seventh (7th!!!) Games. With that, we sat down for a virtual chat on payments and Rio.
Higher ed eCommerce gurus on how to make students and staff happy
I love how honestly and openly schools tell each other what works and what doesn’t. Spalding University and Indiana Wesleyan University recently chatted about how they make students and staff happy. I wish you could have joined us for this eCommerce discussion for clients of Colleague® by Ellucian
But you don’t have to miss out on the best quotes. Here are some of our handpicked highlights.
Alarming Brazilian card fraud trends & outlandish risky behavior
In a recent report “Global Consumers: Losing Confidence In The Battle Against Fraud,” it was found that 30% of consumers have experienced card fraud in the past five years. Against a backdrop of 2,260 confirmed data breaches in 2015 and over 4 billion records stolen since in 2013, consumers are losing faith in the ability of providers to protect them.
South African card fraud trends & risky consumer behavior
In conjunction with the PASA International Payments Conference this week, we decided to take a look at some recent consumer fraud data from the host nation, South Africa. The market is very similar to the global averages, in that a shockingly high number of consumers continue to experience card fraud. Despite the number of fraud attacks and breaches, consumers in South Africa continue to engage in risky behavior such as providing information in phishing attempts and writing down their PIN numbers.
July: the hottest shopping time of the year for consumers, retailers—and fraudsters
Summer is in full swing, and while many people equate this time of year with beach-hopping and BBQs, retailers—and those of us who keep them in business— are quickly making July one of the most exciting shopping months of the year. Irresistible online sales and promotions abound, and with that, so does the risk of fraud. In fact, eCommerce fraud attempt rates in July, 2016 (1.6%) are slightly higher than fraud rates in December, 2015 (1.2%), which is the busiest holiday shopping time of the year.