Should banks be held liable for Ponzi schemes?
Friday, December 16, 2011
Posted by ACI Worldwide
Ponzi schemes were named for Charles Ponzi after he defrauded customers out of approximately 20 million dollars back in 1920 (over $225 million today).
While the idea of paying out investors with their own money rather than any money earned legitimately via investment had been around prior to 1920, the name Ponzi become synonymous with the scheme based on the amount of publicity and high dollar loss associated with his activity (including the downfall of six financial institutions).
Over the past few years, we’ve seen a tremendous increase in the magnitude of Ponzi schemes. Fingers have been pointed at the fraudsters, as well as the SEC, and more recently, the guilty label is being extended to the financial institutions providing services for the schemes.
In recent cases, the argument made by prosecutors was that the banks were negligent in not identifying red flags for these investor accounts, making them guilty of ‘aiding and abetting’ these criminals. To be guilty of this, in most states in the US, there must be three elements: the existence of fraud, the defendant’s knowledge of the fraud and proof that the defendant provided considerable assistance to the progression of the fraud scheme. Though this is the standard primarily under US law, this does not permit international financial services firms or banks from being included in the lawsuit, as seen in the case against Banco Santander in 2010, which involved defendants from seven different nations around the world.
The question of ‘knowledge’ of the fraud and providing assistance can be a bit subjective, since the banks didn’t know directly about the scheme. The question is: if they didn’t implement the appropriate steps to look for red flags or simply failed pay attention to them, does this make them guilty? For instance, in the Madoff scheme, an activity monitoring system to detect transfers between investor and personal accounts may have triggered an internal review of the activity and shut down accounts before investors were defrauded of the full $50 billion.
So what can banks do to prevent these schemes, and also ensure they are not on the receiving end of a lawsuit? Financial institutions need to implement a sophisticated transaction monitoring tool that is flexible enough to quickly adapt to the changing fraud schemes. Activity monitoring must be implemented across the enterprise, in order to detect complex patterns of activity that may seem normal alone, but when viewed collectively may be a red flag for a large fraud scheme. Taking proactive measures to ensure that your institution is doing everything possible to prevent fraudulent schemes will help protect customers and keep your institution out of the hotseat should a new scheme appear, despite your best prevention efforts.
Related blog posts
Immediate Payments Are "Necessary"—And the Banks Know It
Who says banks are dinosaurs? They just have a lot of innovation to juggle to keep pace. There are so many new initiatives to address—so how should banks prioritize?
DCC Cuestión de Elección y Servicio [DCC: Offering Choice and Service]
We continue our exploration of key trends impacting the Latin America market with a blog on Dynamic Currency Conversion. Many of our reader are seasoned travelers and you will be familiar with the option to pay in the local currency or your own currency using your credit card. Sonia Gomez provides an overview of DCC and how it can benefit all within the payments value chain.
Is Blockchain Ready?
SIBOS is just around the corner and blockchain will undoubtedly be one of the buzzwords at this year’s event (as is the case at pretty much every payments or fintech conference these days). The big question on everyone’s mind is whether blockchain really has the potential to change the global systems that process trillions of dollars in payments every day or whether it’s hype. I recently sat down with Paul Thomalla, ACI’s senior vice president of global corporate relations, to delve deeper into the topic, a topic on which he has just published a white paper.
Why 75% of Lenders Are Adding New Payment Processing Options
“Do you want my money?” I wondered as I left the website of a lender that didn’t accept debit cards. You see when lenders offer new payment processing options they increase dollars collected by 15%. To increase collections and meet growing customer expectations 75% of lenders are currently adding new payment processing options.
The Magical Mystery API Is Waiting to Take You Away…Waiting to Take You Away
There’s nothing like a good mashup of a Beatles song and technology, right? We all know the Beatles, but do we all know APIs? To butcher another Beatles song, ‘All you need are APIs, APIs are all you need.’ At least that’s what it seems like, especially in today’s vast finance industry. Before we quote any more songs, we should first define what an API is. According to our friends at Webopedia, Application Program Interface (API) is a set of routines, protocols, and tools for building software applications. An API specifies how software components should interact and APIs are used when programming graphical user interface (GUI) components.
Payment Service Providers Face Pressures from Many Sides, as Merchant Expectations Rise
The payments industry is more dynamic than ever, and despite the advances that innovation brings, the speed of change is undeniably putting pressure on traditional business models. The roles of acquiring banks and payment service providers (PSPs) – previously quite clearly defined – are blurring, and merchant demands are becoming technologically more complex.
SEPA Instant Payments: The Importance of Real-Time Hubs in a Global Market
An epiphany is happening across Europe—and across the global markets. I’m not talking about the realization of Brexit (and that we’re all going to need to make it work). But rather, the realization that payment hubs that were brought in to manage SEPA batch credit transfers and direct debits are not going to be capable in the real-time world of SEPA Instant Payments.
¿Has Visto Tu Tarjeta de Crédito Últimamente? [Have You Seen Your Credit Card Lately?]
Payments is a global business with local flavors. The following blog is part of a series looking at the payment industry in Latin America. This blog looks at the "invisible card" as you go about your daily routines. The post is available below in both Spanish and English.
Cross-Border Payments: ready, set, go…
The cross-border payments market is probably the most important industry in the world. Trillions of dollars are exchanged every day to cover the settlement of everything from multi-billion-dollar company investments, through to the value of the perishable cargo on the ship that’s stuck in port, all the way down to that rather nice holiday rental I’ve got my eye on for next summer. International payments are essential to everyone, in every country in the world.
As Aetna Pulls Out, How the Member Experience Can Increase Exchange Profitability
My heart sank when I did the math on Aetna withdrawing from many health insurance exchanges due to low profitability. Aetna could have avoided 2/3 of its losses by improving its member experience.
Aetna lost roughly $16 per member per month. But health plans can save up to $11 per member per month by enhancing the member experience. The key lies in automation, consolidation and service fees.